Industry
Manufacturing
Future-Ready Manufacturing: Partnering in your journey to a sustainable manufacturing enterprise
Highlights
- The movement of internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles to an electrified environment has led to massive growth in insurance premiums.
- Original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) are looking to reduce these high insurance prices with innovative automotive solutions.
- In this era of transformation, insurers stand at the forefront, not merely as risk mitigators but as pioneers shaping the future of automotive insurance.
On this page
On this pageinpage
Overview
Insuring a Battery Electric Vehicle (BEV) currently carries a significantly higher cost than covering an ICE vehicle in today’s global market, with premiums rising 72% compared to last year.
This discussion will explore the factors driving these elevated BEV insurance costs, examine potential solutions to the challenge, and outline how OEMs are working to reinforce the broader sustainability narrative.
The global EV market, formerly propelled by Tesla, features vehicles with fewer components, greater sustainability, and often more advanced safety systems than their combustion counterparts, yet many insurers have declined to provide coverage or issued quotes at sharply inflated rates.
This article explores how automotive electrification is affecting the insurance sector. We assessed insights from a range of insurers to understand why BEV insurance costs currently exceed those of ICE vehicles, and to identify how these challenges might be addressed to prevent disruption to global electric sales targets and the wider transition toward sustainability.
Repair Dynamics
EVs differ significantly from ICE vehicles when it comes to maintenance costs. With far fewer components, just 20 to 25 moving parts in the drivetrain compared with 200 to 2000 moving parts in the drivetrain and engine of your average ICE vehicle, naturally resulting in far less frequent service requirements.
Long-term, insurance costs in the global BEV market are expected to decline. However, despite lower maintenance requirements, insurance continues to pose a significant barrier to the growth of global EV sales. Although EVs demand fewer routine services, the UK’s Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT) has projected a shortfall of up to 25,000 qualified technicians and mechanics by 2032, a gap that could further influence future insurance prices due to constrained workforce availability.
As vehicles continue shifting toward gadget and software driven designs, traditional OEMs face rising costs, largely because they must train an entirely new generation of technicians. The complexity of BEV technology can further elevate repair expenses. In contrast, technology first companies such as Tesla, Xiaomi, and BYD are far better positioned to keep these costs down, having already built the in house expertise, software capability and technical infrastructure needed to manage repairs efficiently and at scale.
Tech Advancements
To build a truly customer centric market and deliver a faster, more intuitive user experience, technology must take the lead.
‘Over the air’ (OTA) technology enables wireless software updates without the need for service appointments or vehicle drop offs. These updates can deliver improvements such as brake enhancements, advanced driver assistance features and even upgrades to charging performance and driving range.
Advancements like these could help drive future reductions in insurance costs and shorten maintenance wait times; however, current market data shows that BEV claims remain 25.5% higher and take 14% longer to repair than their ICE counterparts.
In addition, the adoption of driver assistance and autonomous technologies, while contributing to higher repair costs, can help lower insurance premiums by offering a safer driving experience. Looking ahead, fully autonomous vehicles, once fully developed and integrated into the electrified market, have the potential to further reduce costs as increased reliance on advanced AI systems is expected to decrease the frequency of incidents.
Lower EV price tags
Insurers must stay aligned with the latest technological developments across automotive models to justify their pricing and accurately reflect the liability associated with both the vehicle and its driver.
Not considering the vehicle’s safety features, Tesla’s previously adopted giga casting (which they have since retreated from) vision aimed to merge multiple components into a single structural piece, potentially lowering per unit manufacturing costs and helping reduce the overall price of EVs. However, while this streamlines production, the use of a singular cast component may drive insurance prices upward due to the repair challenges it creates. A failure in any part of the structure often requires replacing the entire giga cast section, making the process costly and operationally unsustainable.
With an anticipation of a shortage of technicians in many OEMs, a potential situation that might arise is a vehicle would be ‘cheaper’ to write-off than to repair – again increasing insurance premiums and carbon footprints.
Insurance Solutions
Insurance for a BEV differs significantly from that of an ICE vehicle, extending well beyond standard maintenance and liability costs. Coverage must also account for risks such as battery damage and theft, along with additional liabilities related to charging - ranging from charging station incidents to tripping hazards caused by charging cables.
The average cost of insuring an EV varies widely, ranging from around £403 for an electric MINI to £903 for a Tesla Model 3. Premiums are also influenced by factors such as driver age, postcode, and even occupation. As emerging risks and technological complexities continue to shape the market, insurance prices are likely to rise further. With the average EV battery costing more than £5,000 in the UK, insurers must adjust their pricing to reflect the growing financial exposure associated with repairs and replacements.
EV telematics, by contrast, can capture real time data from the vehicle and transmit it directly to insurers, effectively acting as an enhanced form of the traditional black box. By providing detailed insights into driving behaviour and vehicle performance, these systems offer insurers greater confidence in risk assessment, which can ultimately help lower premiums across the electrified market.
Luxury OEMs
Range Rover owners in the UK can now access new insurance coverage introduced in October 2023, designed specifically to help address the sharp rise in premiums across the market.
The insurance provides a flexible buying and ownership experience, enabling clients to obtain quotes online, manage monthly subscriptions, and adjust policy coverage with ease. The fully comprehensive cover guarantees that repairs are carried out by authorised body shops using genuine parts, with no deposits or interest fees. To broaden the range of available policies, Jaguar Land Rover has shared vehicle data with leading insurers, and its latest models have demonstrated strong resistance to theft.
As OEMs begin integrating insurance offerings into their wider ownership models, it is likely that similar solutions will soon extend to their electric vehicles. This shift has the potential to catalyse a broader reduction in EV insurance premiums by creating more competitive, transparent, and data driven pricing structures.
Conclusion
The shift toward electrification across the automotive industry is set to reshape existing insurance practices, prompting insurers to adapt to new technologies, risks, and ownership models.
As EVs become firmly embedded within the automotive industry, insurers must navigate a rapidly evolving landscape shaped by shifting repair dynamics, emerging risks, and increasingly sophisticated vehicle technologies. These challenges are being met with innovative solutions; from EV specific insurance products and usage based models powered by real time telematics to OEMs introducing their own integrated insurance offerings. While such developments may help ease the cost of EV ownership, advancements like giga casting can simultaneously drive premiums upward by increasing repair complexity. Addressing these pressures will require collaboration, investment, and forward thinking strategies across the sector.
In this period of transformation, insurers stand not only as risk managers but as key contributors to the future of mobility. Success will depend on adapting policies, embracing technological progress, and fostering industry wide cooperation to ensure insurance remains effective and relevant in an electrified era. As EVs continue to redefine the automotive landscape, insurers play a pivotal role in ensuring that the transition to a safer, more sustainable, and technologically advanced future is not only supported but confidently and comprehensively insured.